Chocolate Pudding Pie – Grandma’s Way

October 16, 2012 by Kenmore

This pie is made from scratch and includes coffee! I decided to make pudding from scratch after watching my grandma whip up pudding on her stove top. She ran out of the boxed mix she kept on hand, but years of making it from scratch had imprinted the recipe on her brain. She was beautiful and efficient and I was inspired. Grandma is gone now, but every time I make pudding I think of her.


preparation time
0 mins

cook time




1 Baked and cooled pie crust Homemade is better, but use what you want!

1 cup Dutch-processed cocoa powder

1 cup Cornstarch

2 cup Granulated white sugar

1 Salt

1 teaspoons Instant coffee (optional)

1 cup Milk (I use 2%)

1 teaspoons Vanilla Extract


Step 1

Place all dry ingredients together in a saucepan and mix until combined.

Step 2

Very slowly add in the milk stirring the whole time.

Step 3

Cook over medium heat while stirring slowly and constantly until mixture thickens and starts to boil. Let the pudding boil for 30-45 seconds while you stir.

Step 4

Remove pan from heat and stir in vanilla.

Step 5

Pour pudding into baked pie crust.

Step 6

Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours. When using homemade pudding be sure to place plastic wrap directly onto the pudding to avoid a pudding skin.

Step 7

Add your choice of topping before serving. I chopped up two peanut butter cups and placed them on top of the pie. Other ideas include whipped cream, Andes mints, or Butterfinger.


The Kenmore brand represents 100 years of trusted performance, backed by exclusive features and innovations that no other brand can bring to the table. We’re always evolving to ensure day-to-day tasks are taken care of with faster cooking, better cleaning and more living throughout the home.